Answer

A nuisance per se is an act, occupation, or structure that is a nuisance at all times and under all circumstances, regardless of its location or surroundings — it is a nuisance in and of itself, such as a thing that is a direct menace to public health or safety. A nuisance per accidens is a nuisance only because of the particular location, surroundings, or manner in which it is conducted or maintained; a lawful and useful business may become a nuisance per accidens by reason of the circumstances.

The distinction is decisive for how a nuisance may be abated. A nuisance per se may be summarily abated without judicial proceedings. A nuisance per accidens may not — it requires a prior judicial determination that the thing is in fact a nuisance before it may be abated, because whether it is a nuisance depends on evidence of the surrounding facts.

Researching Philippine law? Intellegal brings Philippine case-law search, statute and issuance exploration, multi-dimension case comparison, document visualization, and cited deep-research reports into a single workflow — with every citation traced back to its original source, so you can verify each answer rather than take it on trust. Every authority it surfaces links back to its original provision or decision, so you can open the source and confirm the wording yourself, and save or export the questions and reports you reference most. See the full report for the statutes and cases behind this answer, or explore the related questions below.

Sources & further reading

Cases on this topic

Philippine Supreme Court decisions that apply the rules above.

Related questions

Read the full report →
Research aid — not legal advice. Verify the current text against the Official Gazette. Provisions may have been amended or repealed. Using this page creates no attorney-client relationship. For legal advice, consult a Philippine lawyer.